England and Australia question Snickometer reliability in Adelaide Ashes Test

Ashes rivals England and Australia were united in their growing bemusement at the reliability of the Snickometer technology on day two of the third Test in Adelaide.

The DRS technology, designed to assist umpires on edges based on audio output from the stump microphone, came under fire on the opening day when Australia’s Alex Carey was wrongly reprieved.

He nicked the ball on 72 but was spared after an operator error produced an unreliable soundwave that showed a pronounced gap between the noise and the ball passing the bat.

Australia scored another 76 runs before Carey was finally dismissed for a century.

For exclusive stories and all the detailed cricket news you need, subscribe to The Cricket Paper website, digital edition, or newspaper from as little as 14p a day.

Criticism

England took the matter to match referee Jeff Crowe, who duly restored their lost review in what amounted to an admission that they had been wronged, but that was not the end of the matter.

There were further problems on Thursday as it became clear that none of those involved had confidence in the ‘Snicko’ system, which had also attracted criticism in the first Test at Perth.

Australia were sure they had Jamie Smith caught off the glove on 16, but the Snicko verdict sided with the England batter, who indicated that the ball had hit only his helmet.

There were also doubts over the slip catch, which looked close to hitting the ground, but that was not the reason for the not out verdict.

Sacked

Pace bowler Mitchell Starc was heard on the stump microphone offering a withering assessment.

“Snicko needs to be sacked. That’s the worst technology there is,” he said.

“They make a mistake the other day and they make another mistake today.”

Marnus Labuschagne was also heard making light of the concussion check Smith was obliged to undergo, clearly doubting he had been struck on the helmet at all.

Confusion

The confusion continued when Smith was given out shortly after, caught behind pulling Pat Cummins.

Australia were sure they had their man, Smith appeared to think he was innocent, but umpire Nitin Menon only added to the sense of uncertainty by signalling for a TV review himself, having failed to give a decision.

Smith was then given out despite yet another syncing issue that showed a spike one frame early. He threw his arms in surprise, with former England spinner Graeme Swann among those venting their fury.

“I don’t want to sound like a whingeing pom, but it seems like one rule for one and one for another. Throw snicko away – it’s nonsense,” he said on TNT Sport.

Ridiculous

Alex Hartley on Test Match Special was equally aghast.

“This is ridiculous. Absolutely ridiculous. This is where Snicko needs sacking,” she said.

“Jamie Smith is convinced he didn’t hit it. Australia have gone up and made a loud noise because everybody knows you don’t trust Snicko now, so you appeal for everything and review it if you have to.”

BBG, which offered a statement accepting responsibility for the Carey error, did not give a formal response on this occasion but is understood to have told broadcasters it felt both Smith decisions were correct.

READ MORE: England question ‘Snickometer’ after Australia’s Alex Carey admits he was lucky