England’s spin in the Ashes: Can the counties deliver the missing link?

By Megh Mandaliya

When England unveiled their 16-member Ashes squad last week, much of the intrigue fixated not on the headline names but on the untested. 

With Shoaib Bashir and the two-Test-old Will Jacks included, England once again parachutes to nascent promise rather than proven pedigree. 

As is often the case, this is a recognisable trend for England, who have traditionally set tours with hope but without a spinner capable of truly dictating terms on the Australian soil.

For exclusive stories and all the detailed cricket news you need, subscribe to The Cricket Paper website, digital edition, or newspaper from as little as 14p a day.

A history of struggles

As history proves, this is familiar territory. Since the turn of the millennium, England has relied on a quintet of frontline spinners, boasting Ashley Giles, Monty Panesar, Graeme Swann, and, most recently, Jack Leach. 

Only Swann has reaped clear rewards as an English spinner down under, claiming 15 wickets at 39.8 in the 2010-11 Ashes that crowned England’s last away triumph. 

Before and after him, the numbers are sobering. The ‘King of Spain’ himself, Giles, toiled through the 2002–03 series but ended with a bruising average of 50.3. 

Another left-arm orthodox spinner, Panesar, lit up Perth with a five-for, yet his 2006–07 tour was otherwise marked by ineffectiveness. 

Panesar returned to Australia in 2013-14 alongside Graeme Swann, but after a bruising start, the latter retired mid-series. Panesar managed just three wickets in four innings as England slumped to a 5–0 whitewash.

Jack Leach’s most recent Ashes stint in 2021–22 was brave if not incisive, but his six wickets at 53.5 told the story of a spinner who lacked the bite required on Australian pitches

England spinners in Australia since 2000

Why one spinner matters so much in Australia

The Kookaburra ball, flat decks, marathon days under a punishing sun make Australia one of the sternest challenges in world cricket without balance. 

The new ball invariably brings seamers into the contest, but once it softens, the spinner must hold firm, extract bounce, and chip away with patience. 

Swann’s role in 2010-11 extended beyond his wicket tally. By locking down one end, he freed England’s seamers the licence to strike in bursts. Australia’s Nathan Lyon has done the same for over a decade. 

With the know-how of three home Ashes series behind him, the 37-year-old Lyon has snared 56 wickets on home soil in Ashes contests, averaging 27.7. 

Remarkably, Lyon’s sole five-for came in Australia during his first home Ashes series, but when the ball loses its shine, his ability to attack with subtle variations is invaluable.

The contrast, one world-class spinner versus a rotating cast of hopefuls, has held sway over the result.

Without a figure like Swann, England have often been left exposed, seamers running on empty, batters afforded stability, and the game sliding out of reach.

It is not hyperbole to say that one spinner can tilt an entire Ashes series.

England’s current gamble

This is why the inclusion of Jacks and Bashir, while gallant, feels both exciting and precarious.

One is a tall off-spinner who is expected to coax bounce from the deck, the other a multi-dimensional spin-batter able to deliver steadiness and surprise in equal measure. 

Yet between them, they have fewer than 25 Test matches. 

To demand they shoulder the burden in Australia prematurely is to risk continuing the pattern, promising spinners cast into the deep end without the hardened skills to cope with the cauldron of an Ashes series.

The question, then, is why England continually find themselves scrambling for spin options.

The root of the problem

For all the focus on tours abroad, the roots of England’s spin crisis stretch back to home. Come April and May, county cricket tilts decisively towards seam.

With lush surfaces and damp conditions, captains seldom turn to spin while the quicks are getting assistance. 

Even with the sun high and the pitches baked in July and August, many counties use their slow bowlers in short, casting them as defensive bursts rather than as attacking options. 

At Somerset, Bashir has shown promise, yet even at Taunton, often billed as one of the scarce spin-friendly venues in England, seam still dictates terms. 

In the 2024 County Championship, Bashir bowled just 113 overs across the season, taking only 4 wickets at an average of 94.25.

Meanwhile, seamers like Lewis Gregory (204.3 overs, 31 wickets at 24.87) and Craig Overton (354.1 overs, 32 wickets at 33.34) still dominated Somerset’s attack. 

Containment over conquest

In South London, similarly, Jacks is often used in white-ball cricket but rarely allowed to toil through full four-day stints.

The right-arm off-spinner has logged slightly more than 135 overs across the last two county seasons with Surrey, with 12 scalps to his name. 

The pattern is clear across the circuit, control is prized over wickets, and spinners are rarely afforded the volume of overs required to grow.

This breeds a generation of spinners trained to contain rather than conquer, precisely what England so often lack when they arrive in Australia. 

There may be flashes from Bashir and Jacks, maybe even enough to turn a Test. Yet history tempers the optimism.

An Ashes can turn on the skill of one spinner. England’s wait for such a figure from their domestic system endures.

READ MORE: Cricket analysis and opinion: The Asia Cup’s hidden game